Anna, a high school senior and undeniable queen of campus, has a knack for getting things her way. She even orchestrated her crush, Colton, into asking her to the town's biggest event, the winter dance. But when the dance is moved to Christmas Eve, Anna's Christian parents inform her that she can no longer attend in lieu of a church service. Anna makes a desperate wish that her parents would lose their faith and her wish is granted. Anna enjoys her newfound freedom until her faithless parents cause Colton and his father to lose their home. Anna embarks on a mission to bring her parents back to their faith. But when her goal fails she discovers that it is her own journey that needs tending.